As the 2022 college lacrosse seasons concludes, 28 Penguins Alumni are competing in conference playoffs for their respective NCAA teams at Division I, II and III.
| Name | School | Penguins Team |
| Adrian Enchill | Brown University | Penguins 2017 |
| Conor Lenfest | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2017 |
| Ryan Birch | Bentley University | Penguins 2018 |
| Jarrod Sweeney | Nichols College | Penguins 2018 |
| Scott Ehrenberg | Nichols College | Penguins 2018 |
| Kyle McEniry | Springfield College | Penguins 2018 |
| Chris Palin | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2018 |
| Matt Palin | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2018 |
| Darragh Fahey | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2018 |
| Jack Ranta | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2018 |
| Sean Lazzaro | Wentworth Institute of Technology | Penguins 2018 |
| Jamaurie James | Western New England University | Penguins 2018 |
| Demitri Papoulis | Babson College | Penguins 2019 |
| Trevor Koppy | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2019 |
| Padraig Flynn | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2019 |
| Luke Murphy | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2019 |
| Ben Kolb | Western New England University | Penguins 2019 |
| Tim Kolb | Western New England University | Penguins 2019 |
| Tucker Crowley | Bentley University | Penguins 2020 |
| Marc Hirshom | Plymouth State University | Penguins 2020 |
| Otto Kirleis | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2020 |
| Brendan King | Wentworth Institute of Technology | Penguins 2020 |
| Liam Hill | Catholic University | Penguins 2021 |
| Brady Morgan | Nichols College | Penguins 2021 |
| Collin Norred | Springfield College | Penguins 2021 |
| Sean Cullagh | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2021 |
| Max Ranta | University of Massachusetts Boston | Penguins 2021 |
| Marty Barrett | Wentworth Institute of Technology | Penguins 2021 |
